When two guests arrive at Grey House and are immediately at odds, Cassie uses her magic to bring them together; Sam tries to plan the perfect date for Cassie, but various nuisances keep getting in the way.
The town is caught up in romance when Cassie helps Ben find an old film to show at opening night of the refurbished Middleton Theater; Martha's promises to the town are in jeopardy when she overextends herself with the budget.
With a case of writer's block, a children's author escapes to small town Mitford for a change of scenery. She soon finds the heart and soul of the southern town in a priest as they work together to care for a young boy.
When a beloved neonatal intensive care unit supervisor is forced to take early retirement, her young colleague, Jenny, decides to turn the upcoming staff Christmas party into a surprise celebration for her.