Matlock decks the halls of justice, defending the Scrooge-like owner of a toy store accused of killing his business partner after firing the Santa he hired.
Cassie gives a withdrawn traveling artist a new paintbrush and invites him to stay at Grey House; Cassie arranges for her and Sam to organize the Tri-Cities Healthfest, something that Cassie usually does by herself.
Cassie decides to plan a surprise party for Sam to celebrate the anniversary of his move to Middleton; Grace uses her powers to create situations where she and Noah can get together, but Nick keeps getting in the way.
Aurora and her new neighbor, a handsome professor named Nick, investigate when four students from a nearby college (including her cousin) go missing. Stars Candace Cameron Bure.
A taunting clue left for Aurora at a meeting begins a cat-and-mouse game between her and a mysterious criminal who commits increasingly serious crimes that leave the town rattled. Candace Cameron Bure, Niall Matter, Marilu Henner.
When Sally's wealthy aunt Gladys, dies from poisoning after giving a wedding toast, Aurora inspects if Glady's will hints at who may have wanted her gone. Stars Candace Cameron Bure, Niall Matter, Marilu Henner.
